Comité Fronterizo
de Obrer@s


For the labor rights and all human rights of the maquiladora workers

Home> CFO in the Media 2005
Spanish Version



Taglines: Exploited Workers?  “Exploitation or just good business”?


CNN - Lou Dobbs Show
Aired July 22, 2005 - 18:00   ET



DOBBS: Now, the economic sham some call free trade. American corporations setting up factories overseas in their quest for cheap labor. One company, Alcoa, operates a plant in Acuna, Mexico, just across the U.S. border. Workers there are paid a barely subsistent living wage by comparison to the United States. But now Alcoa is threatening to shift the jobs there to Honduras where workers are paid even less than their Mexican counterparts. Bill Tucker has our report.


BILL TUCKER, CNN CORRESPONDENT (voice over): Many of the people in this neighborhood work in Maquiladoras, factories owned by multinational companies employing Mexican labor. The practice has the full support of the United States.

GEORGE W. BUSH, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: It will improve -- boost demands for our goods. It'll help them reduce poverty. See, as wealth spreads out through the neighborhood, it will help create a vibrant middle class.

 TUCKER: This neighborhood is three miles from the border with America. The workers we spoke to are production line workers for Alcoa. The factories they work in stand in stark contrast to the living conditions of the workers. The average wage of $1.21 an hour is not enough, the workers told us, to live on. This woman's husband has worked for Alcoa for 14 years, her family can't afford many basic necessities

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE, (through translator): I am unable to eat meat every day. I can't have fruit every day.

TUCKER: All of the workers we spoke to would only speak if they remained anonymous, for fear of reprisals by the company. A fear that Alcoa told us is unfounded. Still the workers are afraid, afraid because the company has made it clear that labor costs are cheaper in it's new plant in Honduras, where two workers can be hired for the price of one here in Acuna.

UNIDENTIFIED (through translator): They've been threatening us all along, every time we talk salaries, that's what they come up with, threats.

TUCKER: To make up the difference between their paycheck and their bills, some workers at the Piedras Negras plant sell their blood across the Rio Grande River in Eagle Pass, Texas, where they can make an additional $45 a week. In response, Alcoa defends its wages saying that it pays among the highest wages in whatever regions it operates. The company characterizes itself as being very aggressive on cost controls, because if it doesn't keep pressure on wages and drive down cost it will lose business to competitors who will undercut them, and have competing factories in the same regions.

TUCKER (on camera): Proponents of exporting jobs out of America to foreign countries, argue that it raises the standard of living for the local workers in that country. Opponents say the only ones who benefit are the corporations.

CHARLES KERNAGHAN, NATIONAL LABOR COMMITTEE: I would say the NAFTA has failed the workers in Mexico and the United States and now they are pitting NAFTA against CAFTA. And CAFTA is going to be another step down.

TUCKER (voice-over): According to research by the National Labor Committee, wages in Honduras are 65 cents an hour, in Nicaragua, 41 cents and in Haiti, 30 cents an hour.

Bill Tucker, CNN, Acuña, Mexico.



    is produced in cooperation with the
Mexico-U.S Border Program
of the American Friends Service Committee (AFSC)

Comité Fronterizo de Obrer@s (CFO)
Monterrey #1103, Col. Las Fuentes
Piedras Negras, Coahuila
C.P. 26010, México